WHEN
IT
COMES
to
movies,
everybody’s
a
critic.
And
when
it
comes
to
the
Oscars,
there’s
plenty
of
criticism
to
go
around
this
year.
Some
gays
are
upset
that
"Brokeback
Mountain"
lost
to
"Crash"
for
Best
Picture.
Others
are
upset
that
Felicity
Huffman
didn’t
win
Best
Actress
for
her
performance
in
"Transamerica."
A
few
are
concerned
about
the
message
sent
by
the
selection
of
Philip
Seymour
Hoffman
as
Best
Actor
for
his
role
as
a
manipulative
gay
writer
in
"Capote."
And
some
blacks
are
upset
that
Three
6
Mafia
won
an
Oscar
for
the
degrading
song,
"It’s
Hard
Out
Here
For
A
Pimp."
That’s
a
lot
of
criticism
for
an
Oscar
awards
ceremony
that
was
one
of
the
most
progressive
in
years.
I
understand
the
concerns,
but
let’s
not
lose
sight
of
the
big
picture.
I
often
disagree
with
the
Academy
Awards
nominees
and
winners,
and
this
year
was
no
exception.
But
this
year
was
also
unusual
because
of
the
political
content
featured
in
many
of
the
most
celebrated
films.
I
understand
the
frustration
expressed
by
gays
who
had
hoped
"Brokeback
Mountain"
would
serve
as
a
vehicle
to
wake
up
homophobic
America,
but
the
gay
criticism
really
misses
the
point.
To
complain
about
"Crash"
beating
"Brokeback
Mountain"
is
like
complaining
about
Martin
Luther
King,
Jr.,
winning
a
Nobel
Prize
instead
of
Harvey
Milk.
They’re
both
great
films
and
they
both
offer
radical
challenges
to
the
political
status
quo
in
this
country,
and
that
should
be
celebrated.
"CRASH"
OFFERED
A
refreshing
critique
of
racism
in
America,
and
"Brokeback"
presented
the
effects
of
homophobia.
Other
nominated
films
also
pushed
the
envelope.
"Good
Night,
and
Good
Luck"
critiqued
the
right-wing
fear-mongering
that
silenced
free
speech
in
the
1950s
and
today.
"Syriana"
exposed
the
corruption
between
government
and
big
oil
companies
in
the
Middle
East.
"North
Country"
showed
us
the
dangers
of
sexual
harassment
in
the
workplace
and
the
conditions
of
the
American
mining
industry.
Even
"Hustle
&
Flow"
showed
us
a
more
human
side
of
life
in
the
hood.
I
can’t
ever
remember
a
time
in
Oscar
history
when
so
many
nominated
films
challenged
the
prevailing
norms
in
society.
But
rather
than
celebrating
the
achievements
of
our
allies,
we
too
often
find
ourselves
engaged
in
self-destructive
battles
that
allow
our
conservative
enemies
to
divide
and
conquer
us.
We
pit
blacks
against
gays
and
women
against
labor,
and
we
don’t
bother
to
see
the
connections
that
could
align
us.
"Brokeback"
may
not
have
won
the
top
honor
at
the
Oscars,
but
it
did
win
others,
and
in
the
process
it
opened
the
door
for
other
filmmakers
to
tell
their
own
stories.
"Crash"
may
have
done
the
same
thing
by
telling
stories
about
race
relations
with
its
multiracial
cast.
But
even
if
neither
film
had
won,
they
didn’t
need
Oscars
to
validate
their
work.
The
millions
of
people
who
saw
the
films
and
were
inspired
by
them
have
already
done
that.
Now
it’s
time
for
artists,
actors,
studios,
writers
and
filmmakers
to
continue
the
tradition.