IN
A
1999
interview,
then-Gov.
George
W.
Bush
responded
to
a
question
about
tolerance
toward
discriminated-against
groups,
including
homosexuals,
by
saying,
“I
think
that
each
person
ought
to
be
judged
by
their
heart
and
by
their
soul
and
by
their
contribution
to
society.
Group-thought
will
‘Balkanize’
our
society,
and
I
have
rejected
the
politics
of
pitting
one
group
of
personas
against
another.”
It
is
hard
to
imagine
that
so
much
can
change
so
quickly.
That
change
was
reflected
in
a
Republican
National
Convention
grounded
in
“group-thought”
and
a
political
calculation
to
pit
Americans
against
each
other.
The
contrast
between
the
two
party
conventions
could
not
have
been
starker.
It
is
a
contrast
that
showed
itself
long
before
the
conventions
were
formally
convened.
Leading
up
to
the
convention,
the
Democratic
platform
committee
set
forth
a
statement
of
principles
endorsing
inclusion
and
condemning
discrimination.
Those
principles
were
reflected
at
the
convention
by
the
participation
of
Americans
from
all
walks
of
life,
including
gay
and
lesbian
delegates.
I
was
honored
when
the
Democratic
National
Committee
named
me
the
first
out
gay
vice
chair
of
any
national
political
party
convention.
JOHN
KERRY,
RECOGNIZING
that
gay
and
lesbian
Americans
care
about
the
same
issues
that
all
Americans
are
concerned
with
—
health
care,
jobs,
quality
education
and
a
clean
environment
—asked
me
to
deliver
opening
night
remarks
on
the
issue
of
health
care.
The
symbolism
of
the
moment
was
not
lost
on
me.
That
night,
standing
on
the
shoulders
of
gay
men
and
lesbians
throughout
America,
I
spoke
to
all
Americans
of
our
common
concern.
Anyone
watching
the
convention
could
see
a
true
picture
of
the
“face
of
America.”
Delegates
included
small
business
owners
and
workers,
young
and
old,
and
people
of
all
social,
financial,
religious
and
ethnic
backgrounds,
as
well
as
many
from
the
LGBT
community.
A
sign
of
the
home
our
community
has
found
in
the
Democratic
Party
could
be
seen
in
the
extraordinary
turnout
for
the
LGBT
caucus.
More
than
300
conventioneers
gathered
to
celebrate
our
active
role
in
the
party.
Americans
watching
the
convention
received
a
clear
message
that
all
are
welcome
in
the
Democratic
Party,
and
that
John
Kerry
values
each
and
every
American.
THE
SPIRIT
AT
the
GOP
convention
was
quite
different.
In
an
atmosphere
of
“group-thought”
and
a
climate
hostile
to
LGBT
Americans,
the
Republican
platform
committee
—
filled
with
representatives
from
extremist
organizations
—
rejected
the
efforts
of
the
Log
Cabin
Republicans
and
their
supporters
to
include
a
unity
plank
in
their
platform.
The
simple
statement
of
inclusion
was
rejected
in
favor
of
platform
language
that
conservative
columnist
Robert
Novak
wrote
was
“dictated
by
Bush.”
For
four
nights,
the
GOP
that
used
to
say
it
had
a
“big
tent”
decried
dissent
on
the
war
and
challenged
the
patriotism
of
every
American
who
has
spoken
out
against
the
actions
of
the
Bush
administration.
Repeated
references
to
Sept.
11
never
mentioned
the
extraordinary
sacrifices
of
gay
and
lesbian
Americans
during
that
national
crisis,
from
New
York
Fire
Department
chaplain
Father
Mychal
Judge,
to
Carol
Flyzik
and
Mark
Bingham,
and
so
many
more.
Many
of
these
victims
left
behind
longtime
partners
and
families
who
sacrificed
as
well.
But
instead
of
recognizing
the
value
of
those
relationships,
the
president
chose
to
use
his
convention
speech
to
equate
respect
for
LGBT
families
with
a
threat
to
the
institution
of
marriage.
ONE
AMERICAN
WHO
felt
quite
at
home
at
the
convention
was
conservative
columnist
Alan
Keyes,
the
GOP
candidate
for
the
U.S.
Senate
in
Illinois,
who
was
quick
to
label
the
vice
president’s
daughter
a
“selfish
hedonist,”
rhetoric
that
President
Bush
declined
to
condemn.
Is
it
any
wonder
that
Mary
Cheney
decided
not
to
join
her
family
on
stage?
As
her
father
and
George
W.
Bush
launched
their
campaign,
they
made
it
clear
to
all
Americans
that
theirs
was
a
party
of
division
and
hostility.
John
Kerry
and
John
Edwards
welcomed
all
to
join
them.
They
are
proud
to
stand
with
all
of
us.
The
choice
for
LGBT
voters
has
often
been
clear,
but
never
before
have
the
stakes
been
so
high.