Southern Voice
Email:   Password:   login or create account

HOME > NEWS > LOCAL    
spacer Sandy Ketchum (left) and Holly Harvey face multiple charges related to the slaying of Harvey’s grandparents. A judge denied bond for the teens on Aug. 19. (Photos by R.O. Youngblood)
spacer
Attorney doubts role of lesbian relationship in killings
Teens denied bond as attorney questions if fair trial can be held

By DYANA BAGBY
AUG. 27, 2004
spacer
More from this author
DYANA BAGBY

  Sound Off! about this article

  Printer-friendly

  E-Mail this story

  Letter to the Editor

An attorney for a teen charged with killing her elderly grandparents to continue a lesbian relationship says the alleged romantic connection “had nothing to do with what happened.”

Holly Harvey, 15, and Sandy Ketchum, 16, are charged with the Aug. 2 slayings of Harvey’s grandparents, Carl and Sarah Collier. Law enforcement authorities claim the two hatched a plan to brutally stab the couple to death as part of a plot so they could remain together.

“I’ve said Sandy was in it for the love,” Lt. Col. Bruce Jordan of the Fayette County Sheriff’s Department told Southern Voice this week. “I kind of feel Sandy is a victim, as much as she can be a victim. She was manipulated [by Harvey]. But I can’t really go into the evidence about this.”

The teens are both charged as adults with one count each of felony murder, malice murder and armed robbery. They face up to life in prison, but cannot be sentenced to death because of their age, according to Fayette County District Attorney Bill McBroom.

The teens were denied bond by Fayette County Superior Court Judge Paschal English on Aug. 19 after being described as flight risks by Jordan. No testimony was presented about a relationship between the girls during the 35-minute hearing at the Fayette County Justice Center in Fayetteville, a city south of Atlanta.

Jordan said more evidence of the girls’ relationship might be presented at a preliminary hearing Aug. 31.

Harvey and Ketchum remain in separate juvenile detention centers and have had no contact with each other since their arrest Aug. 3, according to authorities.

Harvey’s court-appointed attorney, Judy Chidester of Peachtree City, said after the bond hearing that her client’s relationship with Ketchum is inconsequential to the tragedy.

“I think it’s inappropriate police have released such information,” Chidester said. “This didn’t have anything to do with what happened. I think [the relationship] is a misdirection.”

When Ketchum’s attorney, Lloyd Walker, was asked about the girls’ alleged lesbian relationship, he said bluntly, “I’m not going to discuss that.”

Dr. Barbara Rubin, a gay Atlanta psychologist, said the teens are clearly troubled with serious mental health issues, none of which have to do whether or not they are lesbians.

“This is not a gay story,” she said. “They didn’t do this because they are gay.”


No chance of fair trial?

Harvey and Ketchum were arrested in Tybee Island on Aug. 3 after fleeing the Fayette County home where Harvey lived with her grandparents. The two took the Collier’s blue Chevy Silverado truck to make their escape to the coastal city about 250 miles from Atlanta, according to a Fayette County Sheriff’s Department report.

Fayette prosecutors added the armed robbery charges at the Aug. 19 hearing. Harvey and Ketchum also allegedly stole some of Harvey’s grandmother’s jewelry, according to prosecutors.

The bodies of the Colliers, both stabbed more than a dozen times, were discovered by law enforcement authorities after a Griffin teen called 911 to report Harvey and Ketchum came by her home and claimed to have killed Harvey’s grandparents, according to Spalding County Sheriff’s Deputy Cheryl Brown.

The Griffin teen said both girls were covered in blood and asked the friend for a change of clothes and to wash up, Brown said.

Spalding County Sheriff’s officials contacted the Fayette Sheriff’s office, which sent deputies to the Riverdale home where the Colliers lived and confirmed they had been killed.

Harvey and Ketchum then apparently made other calls to friends on a cell phone. Police traced these calls to Tybee Island where the teens were eventually captured, Jordan said.

During the bond hearing, Harvey, apparently in tears, rested her head on a table for nearly all of the proceeding. Chidester tried to console her by putting her arm around the girl’s shoulder. At one point, Harvey raised her head to ask Chidester a question.

“She asked me, ‘Is there anyone who is going to testify for me?’” Chidester told reporters after the hearing.

Nobody testified for Harvey. Her mother, Carla Harvey — who was adopted by the Colliers — is serving a three-year prison sentence for marijuana possession. The Colliers became Holly Harvey’s guardians after her mother was sentenced.

Holly Harvey’s father, a quadrapalegic and an ex-convict, said he would not testify for his daughter but wanted her to know he was praying for her, Chidester said after the hearing.

“She has nowhere to go,” Chidester said. “And she’s never really had that.”

Testifying for Ketchum, who cried throughout the hearing and wiped tears away with a tissue, were her father and stepmother.

Both teens were described as having a history of drug use ...

continued on next page



1  |  2


email   password
The following comments were posted by our readers and were not edited by SOVO.  We ask that you treat others with respect; any post deemed offensive will be removed.




MORE LOCAL
Local activists say fight for gay marriage not over
Atlanta Prop 8 protests hope to raise awareness of marriage equality

‘Uniting for the greater cause’
Day of Remembrance memorializes transgender dead, brings awareness to the living

All in a day’s work
Meet five Atlantans for whom sex is part of the job

Chambliss, Doyle likely favored in runoffs
Martin relies on Obama organization to beat Chambliss

Butch/femme dynamic thrives in Atlanta women
While some prefer to not be labeled, others proud to identify

Getting to the ‘bottom’ of sex role bias
Despite their strong numbers, Atlanta bottoms still get flack

The queer side of gay sex
A look at unique elements of gay and lesbian sexuality

AIDS impacted gay sexual norms, overall relationships
Disclosure continues to be a source of anxiety for lovers and friends

What do lesbians do in bed, anyway?
For Atlanta women, the answer is all that — and more

Lesbians getting off — on guys going at it
Many queer women find deep pleasure watching gay male porn

Homegrown porn
Atlanta attracts adult movie newcomers and veterans





MOST VIEWED ARTICLES
News:
All in a day’s work
News:
What do lesbians do in bed, anyway?
News:
The queer side of gay sex
News:
Local activists say fight for gay marriage not over
News:
Lesbians getting off — on guys going at it
News:
Homegrown porn




© Copyright 2008 Window Media LLC | User Agreement and Privacy Policy

Washington Blade | South Florida Blade | David Atlanta | The 411 Magazine | Genre Magazine