Southern Voice
Email:   Password:   login or create account

HOME > NEWS > NATIONAL    
spacer David Benkof, formerly known as David Bianco, left behind his life as a gay author and media entrepreneur because it didn't fit with his religious views. (Photo courtesy of Q Syndicate)
spacer
Gay Jewish writer gives up sex with men
Benkof claims faith won't allow same-sex relationships

By CHRISTOPHER SEELY
DEC. 19, 2003
spacer
More from this author
CHRISTOPHER SEELY

  Sound Off! about this article

  Printer-friendly

  E-Mail this story

  Letter to the Editor

As David Bianco, he created a syndication service that provides articles to dozens of gay media outlets, including this newspaper.

As David Benkof, he will soon appear on national television to oppose gay marriage.

When a gay person comes out of the closet, rainbow flags wave and a celebration ensues. But when a gay person opts to pursue opposite-sex relationships, that support turns to silence or even attacks, according to Benkof, whose legal name change will be final next year.

"Nobody gets a parade for leaving the gay community, and I'm one of the more high-profile people to have gone through this transition and been public about it," Benkof said.

Benkof was formerly well known in gay media circles as journalist-entrepreneur David Bianco, who in 1995 founded Q Syndicate, a media service that provides columns, cartoons, crossword puzzles and horoscopes to the gay press.

Now Benkof has come out in opposition to gay marriage, calling it unholy in "J," a weekly northern California Jewish publication.

"Some love relationships can be holy and some — such as those between members of the same sex — cannot," Benkof said in the Nov. 28 edition.

Later this month, he will defend his stance during an appearance on "Ricki Lake" dedicated to the gay marriage debate, he said.

"I believe that marriage is a fundamental bedrock of society that comes from God, that has a specific definition that God gave us, which is a man and a woman," Benkof told Southern Voice.

Benkof's new political views, rooted in his religious convictions, leave gay activists divided over whether Benkof is now an enemy to the gay rights movement he once supported.

"The bottom line is that his religious views themselves are despicable and detestable because they are saying that gay is bad," said Wayne Besen, author of a recent book criticizing "ex-gay" ministries. "Anyone who would say that is not a friend of the gay movement."

But despite Benkof's new beliefs, he is not anti-gay, according to Paula Martinac, editor at Q Syndicate and a former co-worker of Benkof.

"In my opinion, David is neither actively working to 'convert' gay people to heterosexuality nor trying to harm the gay movement," Martinac said. "Although our political views are pretty far apart, 'anti-gay' is not a term I would use for him."


Gays and Judaism
Earlier this year, Benkof began the process of changing his name from Bianco in honor of the 30-year anniversary of the death of his grandfather, Julius Benkof, and "secondarily to reflect that I've changed sexual identity," he said.

In 2001, Benkof sold Q Syndicate to Rivendell Media, another agency closely tied with the gay press that distributes syndicates and works with advertisers that want to reach the gay market.

In September 2003, Benkof severed his ties with the company completely, no longer writing his column, "Over the Rainbow."

"It was increasingly odd to be supervising content for the gay media on a day-to-day basis when in my own life I was moving away from gay identity," Benkof said.

Politically, Benkof said he still supports allowing gays to serve openly in the military and banning employment discrimination based on sexual orientation.

Benkof also supports allowing gays to adopt children, but believes that straight couples should be given priority over gay couples, he said.

"I have tremendous respect for the relationship choices and integrity of my gay friends, but I also have to say that I think opposite-sex relationships are in some way better than same-sex relationships, especially when it comes to raising of children," he said.

"I don't hate the sin, and I don't hate who I was 10 years ago," Benkof said. "Gay sex is just inconsistent with traditional religious life."

But others disagree with Benkof's interpretation of the requirements of Jewish faith.

"I find his version of Judaism to be backwards and at odds with how most American Jews think," Besen said. "Maybe he and Dr. Laura can powwow, but the majority of Jews think it is a slap in the face and an affront to Judaism."

Besen, who is Jewish, authored "Anything but Straight: Unmasking the Scandals and Lies Behind the Ex-Gay Myth," released this year.

Modern knowledge of psychology, sociology and history has changed the role of women in mainstream Judaism and should be considered when examining gays, according to Rabbi Joshua Lesser, leader of Congregation Bet Haverim, a predominately gay Reconstructionist synagogue in Atlanta.

"Judaism has never been an island — it has always shifted and changed in relationship to the knowledge of the day," said Lesser, who is gay. "We ...

continued on next page



1  |  2


email   password
The following comments were posted by our readers and were not edited by SOVO.  We ask that you treat others with respect; any post deemed offensive will be removed.








MOST VIEWED ARTICLES
News:
All in a day’s work
News:
What do lesbians do in bed, anyway?
News:
The queer side of gay sex
News:
Local activists say fight for gay marriage not over
News:
Lesbians getting off — on guys going at it
News:
Homegrown porn



© Copyright 2008 Window Media LLC | User Agreement and Privacy Policy

Washington Blade | South Florida Blade | David Atlanta | The 411 Magazine | Genre Magazine